The Rule: Women in Movies

Tuesday, 20 September 2011, around nine at night.

Every once in a while I’m talk­ing about movies or tele­vi­sion and I’m reminded of the Bechdel Test, which is also known as the Bechdel-​​Wallace Test, the Mo Movie Mea­sure, or sim­ply The Rule. The test comes from a par­tic­u­lar 1985 install­ment of Ali­son Bechdel’s comic strip Dykes to Watch Out For, and is meant to gauge gen­der bias in film and tele­vi­sion. In order to pass, a movie or TV show must:

  1. Include at least two (named) women
  2. Who have at least one con­ver­sa­tion with one another
  3. About some­thing other than men

Try to name a few that pass. It’s eas­ier with TV shows, because the casts are usu­ally larger and the sto­ries can span dozens of episodes. But with movies, where the for­mat gen­er­ally imposes a limit on the num­ber of devel­oped char­ac­ters and plot lines, The Rule is sur­pris­ingly limiting.

The Bechdel Test Movie List pro­vides a forum for review­ing movies based on whether or not they pass the test. As of today there are 2,595 movies listed, and some of the com­ment threads are pretty inter­est­ing. Like any lit­mus test, whether or not a given film passes does not nec­es­sar­ily say much about how “fem­i­nist” that film is. For exam­ple, as is pointed out in the strip, Alien passes the test; how­ever, it does so only because the women talk about the mon­ster they’re try­ing not to get impreg­nated by, rather than the men that their lives revolve around.

Ok, actu­ally, I sup­pose there’s a moun­tain of sub­text there if you look at the movie like that.

In any case, the point is to draw atten­tion to a bias in pop cul­ture — with­out nec­es­sar­ily mak­ing a value judge­ment about it — because it is sur­pris­ingly easy to over­look. Prob­a­bly no one expects an obvi­ous sausage party like The Expend­ables to spend much screen time on the ladies, but did you notice that the lat­est Harry Pot­ter movie fails the test too? I didn’t.